FAIL cut@1700s. Root solved alone by turn 7, then the machinery ran scout/planner/3 reviewers AFTER the fact (~16 of 28 min in children). Reviewer #2 fixed real invalid SPARQL: the result moved from wrong-professor (MinimalPi) to right-professor/wrong-countries — closer, not there. Two harness findings (pi-subagents acceptance-report output loss; preamble RULE 2 suppressing pip-install verification) — see COMMENTS.md + AGENT_TODOS.
💬 1 analyst comment inline below (from runs/fast__qwen3.5-122b-a10b__20260712-184152/COMMENTS.md).
llama-local/qwen3.5-122b-a10bagentharnesses.subagents_pi:SubagentsPithinkingonreasoning budgetdirect (server/none)* — see journal for the authoritative mechanismmaxTokens / contextWindow65536 / 196608agent timeout ×2.0trials1 of 1 — 0 pass · 1 failmean reward0.00tokens (job total)539,295 in / 12,223 outstarted / finished2026-07-12T18:41 / 2026-07-12T19:11wall clock29m09sWhere the 28m20s (cut@1700s) went, from pi.txt + the pi-subagents child metas: the root read the TTL and wrote a solution ITSELF by turn 7 (18.4k chars of thinking on the write turn), found "No SPARQL engine found" (T009) and tried to finish at ~T010. The machinery then pushed it through the full staged workflow AFTER the answer existed: forced reviewer → scout (136s) → planner (166s) → reviewer #1 (437s, output LOST, see below) → reviewer #2 (237s, found a real blocker) → edit → reviewer #3 (still running at the cut). Children ate ~16 of the 28 minutes on the shared slot.
Three concrete findings:
pi-subagents lost a child's report. Reviewer b5ff6e05 worked 7.3 min (8 turns, edited the regex in solution.sparql, ended with a proper ```acceptance-report fenced block, exit 0) but its output.md is EMPTY and the parent saw "(no output)" — the report-extraction appears to eat a final message that is ONLY an acceptance-report block. The parent then (reasonably) ran ANOTHER reviewer, doubling the review cost. Ledger item added.
The reviewer added real value. Reviewer #2 caught invalid SPARQL (SELECT subquery nested in FILTER EXISTS); after the fix the query RUNS and selects the RIGHT professor. Verifier compare: MinimalPi (fast__…144656) returned the WRONG professor row; this run returns the right professor with wrong countries aggregation ('GR' vs 'GR, US' — the EU-filter joins away the professor's US affiliation before GROUP_CONCAT). Closer, not there — the remaining miss is reading-comprehension (countries column = ALL the professor's universities, EU filter only gates selection).
A reviewer-child thinking turn saturated the 8000-token reasoning budget (31.4k chars ≈ 5 min of decode at ~24 t/s) — on the 122b each child is expensive twice: cold prefill on the shared slot + budget-deep thinking. The "no reasoning-loop pathology" note from casual use does not hold under review pressure.
Also: neither harness variant tried pip install rdflib to self-verify —
consistent with preamble RULE 2's "use only the standard library and
already-installed tools" steering away from the ONLY verification path on
this task (the container has network; the verifier itself installs rdflib).
Ledger item added.
| # | result | total | agent | in/out tok | flags | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | FAIL | 29m09s | 28m20s | 539295/12223 | 🔍 view |